District 9

2 replies [Last post]
Califmom
Offline
Joined: 1/7/2010

Wow! Great flick! I love satire. This was darkly, creepily funny. Wonderful script, not an obscenely large budget, interesting cinematography, filmed in South Africa with mostly South African talent, really hideous aliens, fearless filmmaking. The main character has an amazing character arch, and it rings true. Very well done.

As much as I enjoyed Avatar, District 9 should be required viewing as an antidote to the warm fuzzies the first movie engages in so shamelessly. 

I don't want to say more to spoil it as surprise is really important for those who haven't seen it. But still, I'd love to discuss it ...

Libby
Offline
Joined: 12/24/2009

I liked this movie too as well as Avatar, and I often can't sit through a lot of movies. It was interesting and felt very 'real' with the documentary style. I also liked how it dealt with issues of 'racism' by using a neutral entity such as an alien race, not singling out any one ethnic group as the victom or perpetrator. I think this is why South Africa was chosen as the setting.

"Just because someone does not speak, does not mean they have nothing to say."

Califmom
Offline
Joined: 1/7/2010

Hi Libby, 

I'm glad I have company in liking this film.

It's interesting that Peter Jackson insists the movie has no political meaning. Maybe, in the sense that the movie doesn't single any group out, as you point out. Every human interviewed in this mockumentary is equally sincere and horrifying, regardless of ethnicity. Even the aliens are rather horrible collectively, certainly no more noble than any other group. But really no less, either, which I found very interesting.

The two main characters, human and alien, are wonderful creations. Vickhus (sp?) is such a impish, grinning, affable, lovestruck, eerily competent, horrible little Nazi. And the actor who played him had such a good time with him, not to mention the extreme physical demands of playing that role. And Christopher, a guy in a gray suit, overlaid with computer animation, was done remarkably without irony -- the only character who is just played straight, rather than for laughs. And the weird thing is that Christopher quickly became easier to look at than Vickhus did.

All without bambi eyes or cat noses. Very cool. Although I must say I'll never look at cat food in quite the same way ever again! 

I wonder if there was any attempt on the filmmakers' parts to comment on Avatar, or if the cross pollination that occurred was strictly coincidental. The films make excellent bookends.